The Same Power That Raised Jesus Lives in You

Romans 8:11 and the New Covenant Gift of the Indwelling Spirit

But if the Spirit of Him who raised Jesus from the dead dwells in you, He who raised Christ from the dead will also give life to your mortal bodies through His Spirit who dwells in you.Romans 8:11, NKJV

INTRODUCTION: A QUESTION WORTH ASKING

Abraham believed God and it was credited to him as righteousness. David wrote psalms that have comforted millions across three millennia. Elijah called down fire from heaven on Mount Carmel and outran a chariot to Jezreel. These were not spiritually inferior people. They were men and women of profound faith, genuine obedience, and real encounter with the living God.

So here is a question that deserves a serious answer: What, if anything, is genuinely different for the believer who lives after the resurrection of Jesus Christ?

It is not a question many people stop to ask. We assume there must be a difference, but we rarely work out what that difference actually is. And when we fail to understand it, we live beneath our privileges. We may have all the advantages of the New Covenant and yet live as though we are still in the era of the tabernacle — waiting for God to show up, hoping the Spirit does not leave, unsure whether we have access to divine power or only divine instruction.

Romans 8:11 answers the question with breathtaking specificity. Paul does not say the Spirit might possibly dwell in you, or that access to God is a little bit easier since Jesus came. He says that the very Spirit who raised a dead body from a sealed Roman tomb has taken up permanent residence inside you. That is not a metaphor. It is an address change with eternal consequences.

This post walks through what that means — not by diminishing what the Old Testament saints experienced, but by showing what was promised to them that we now possess, and what it means to live in the full light of what God has accomplished through Christ’s cross, resurrection, and ascension.

I. WHAT THE OLD TESTAMENT SAINTS TRULY HAD

We must begin here, because a distorted view of the Old Testament produces a distorted view of the New. Some people speak of Old Covenant believers as though they were entirely on their own — groping in spiritual darkness, sustained by nothing more than external law and sheer willpower. That picture is simply not true, and the Old Testament itself corrects it.

From the very beginning, no one ever came to faith in God apart from the work of the Spirit. When Noah found grace in the eyes of the Lord, that was the Spirit’s regenerating work. When Abraham stepped out of Ur of the Chaldeans with no idea where he was going, trusting nothing but a word from God he had just heard, that was Spirit-produced faith. When Simeon held the infant Jesus in the temple and declared that his eyes had seen salvation, Luke tells us explicitly that the Holy Spirit had revealed this to him (Luke 2:25-26). The Spirit was never absent.

Furthermore, God’s presence among His people was vivid and tangible. He went before Israel as a pillar of cloud by day and fire by night. His glory descended on the completed tabernacle so powerfully that Moses could not enter (Exodus 40:35). He spoke through prophets, judges, and kings. He met His people at the altar, through the sacrificial system, through the annual feasts. Old Testament worship was not colorless; it was immersive, physical, and often overwhelming.

Beyond this, the Spirit came upon specific individuals in remarkable power for specific purposes. Bezalel and Oholiab were filled with the Spirit to design and craft the tabernacle (Exodus 31:3). The Spirit came upon the judges — Othniel, Gideon, Samson — enabling ordinary men to do extraordinary things in battle. He came upon Saul and turned him into another man (1 Samuel 10:6). He descended on David at his anointing, and under His influence David composed poetry that plumbs the depths of the human soul and the heights of divine majesty.

We must not rob the Old Testament saints of what they genuinely had. They had real faith, real encounter, real Spirit-produced fruit. They were not spiritual orphans.

But there was a crack in their armor. And it showed up in the most unexpected place.

II. THE CRACK IN THE ARMOR: PSALM 51 AND DAVID’S FEAR

Do not cast me away from Your presence, and do not take Your Holy Spirit from me.Psalm 51:11, NKJV

This prayer from David — written after the prophet Nathan confronted him over his sin with Bathsheba — is one of the most personal and transparent moments in all of Scripture. It is also one of the most theologically revealing.

David was not a weak believer. He was the man after God’s own heart, a warrior, a poet, a worshiper of unmatched depth. And yet in his deepest moment of repentance, the thing he feared most was not punishment, not the loss of his throne, not even the consequences for his family. It was this: that God would take the Holy Spirit from him.

Why would David fear this? Because he had watched it happen. He had seen with his own eyes what became of Saul after the Spirit departed.

But the Spirit of the LORD departed from Saul, and a distressing spirit from the LORD troubled him.1 Samuel 16:14, NKJV

The contrast between Saul before and after the Spirit’s departure is stark and tragic. The Spirit’s presence in the Old Covenant arrangement was not guaranteed. It was selective and task-specific. It could be withdrawn. And if you had experienced the Spirit’s power, the prospect of losing it was devastating.

This is the defining vulnerability of the Old Covenant relationship with the Spirit: it was precious, it was powerful, and it was precarious. The Spirit came upon people. He empowered them for specific tasks. But He could also depart. There was no permanent seal, no eternal guarantee, no promise of forever.

David’s prayer is the signature prayer of the Old Covenant believer. It is a prayer that New Covenant believers are never called to pray — not because we are more deserving, but because the cross, resurrection, and Pentecost have changed the terms of our access. What David was afraid to lose, you cannot lose.

But how did that change happen? And why did it require the resurrection specifically?

III. THE VALLEY OF DRY BONES: WHAT THE PROPHETS SAW COMING

Long before the resurrection, the prophets knew something was coming. They could not yet experience it, but they described it with extraordinary precision.

Ezekiel’s vision of the valley of dry bones (Ezekiel 37) is one of the most dramatic passages in all of Scripture — and it is explicitly about the Spirit’s life-giving power. God leads the prophet into a valley filled with human bones, bleached and scattered. It is a picture of total spiritual death: hopeless, lifeless, beyond natural remedy.

And then God asks the question: ‘Can these bones live?’ Ezekiel wisely answers: ‘O Lord God, You know.’ And God commands Ezekiel to prophesy to the bones. What happens next is one of the great pictures of resurrection in the Old Testament:

Prophesy to the breath, prophesy, son of man, and say to the breath, “Thus says the Lord GOD: Come from the four winds, O breath, and breathe on these slain, that they may live.” So I prophesied as He commanded me, and breath came into them, and they lived, and stood upon their feet, an exceedingly great army.Ezekiel 37:9-10, NKJV

The Hebrew word here for ‘breath’ and ‘wind’ is ruach — the same word used for the Spirit of God throughout the Old Testament. Ezekiel’s vision is a preview of Pentecost: the Spirit breathing life into a dead and scattered people, raising them up as a vast, living army.

But Ezekiel does not stop there. Just two chapters earlier, he records one of the most sweeping promises in all the Old Testament:

I will give you a new heart and put a new spirit within you; I will take the heart of stone out of your flesh and give you a heart of flesh. I will put My Spirit within you and cause you to walk in My statutes, and you will keep My judgments and do them.Ezekiel 36:26-27, NKJV

Notice the difference between this promise and the Old Covenant experience. The Spirit had come upon specific people for specific tasks. Here, God promises to put His Spirit within His people — universally, internally, transformatively — so that obedience would flow from the inside out rather than being imposed from the outside in.

Joel echoed it: ‘I will pour out My Spirit on all flesh’ (Joel 2:28). Not on judges and kings and prophets alone. On all flesh. Sons and daughters. Old men and young men. Servants and handmaids. This was not the Old Covenant arrangement. This was a promise of something qualitatively new.

When Peter stood up on the day of Pentecost and the crowd demanded an explanation for what they were witnessing, he quoted Joel. The promise had arrived. But it required the resurrection first.

IV. THE HINGE OF HISTORY: CROSS, RESURRECTION, PENTECOST

The resurrection of Jesus is not simply the happy ending to a tragic story. It is the event that makes everything else possible. It is the hinge on which all of redemptive history turns.

Jesus himself made this connection explicit. In John 7:37-39, on the last great day of the Feast of Tabernacles, He cried out: ‘If anyone thirsts, let him come to Me and drink. He who believes in Me, as the Scripture has said, out of his heart will flow rivers of living water.’ John adds the explanatory note: ‘But this He spoke concerning the Spirit, whom those believing in Him would receive; for the Holy Spirit was not yet given, because Jesus was not yet glorified.’

Not yet given. The permanent, universal indwelling of the Spirit could not occur until Jesus was glorified — crucified, resurrected, and ascended. The reason is rooted in the very nature of what had to be accomplished. Sin had to be atoned for. Death had to be defeated. The old covenant had to be fulfilled and the new covenant inaugurated. Not until all of this was accomplished could the Spirit take up permanent residence in believing men and women.

In the upper room, Jesus told His disciples: ‘It is to your advantage that I go away; for if I do not go away, the Helper will not come to you; but if I depart, I will send Him to you’ (John 16:7). That statement would have been baffling to the disciples at the time. How could it be better for Jesus to leave? But Jesus was pointing to the New Covenant reality that His death, resurrection, and ascension would make possible: not the presence of God alongside them in human form, but the presence of God within them through the Spirit.

And when it came — when the day of Pentecost arrived and the Spirit fell on that gathered company in Jerusalem — it was not merely an upgrade to the Old Covenant arrangement. It was the fulfillment of every promise the prophets had spoken. The valley of dry bones came to life. The hearts of stone were replaced with hearts of flesh. The Spirit who had come upon select individuals was now poured out on all flesh.

V. ROMANS 8:11: UNPACKING THE MOST AUDACIOUS VERSE IN THE LETTER

Against this background, Paul’s statement in Romans 8:11 is not a passing theological note. It is one of the most compressed and explosive sentences he ever wrote. It deserves careful attention word by word.

But if the Spirit of Him who raised Jesus from the dead dwells in you, He who raised Christ from the dead will also give life to your mortal bodies through His Spirit who dwells in you.Romans 8:11, NKJV

The Resident: What “Dwells” Actually Means

Paul uses two related Greek words in this verse that carry enormous weight. The primary word is oikeo (G3611), from oikos, meaning ‘house’ or ‘dwelling place.’ It does not mean ‘visits’ or ‘comes upon.’ It means to take up residence — to move in, make your home, settle permanently.

He intensifies this with a participial form — oikountos, ‘the One dwelling’ — to describe the Spirit who already lives there. This is not a conditional arrangement. For the believer, the Spirit has moved in. Your body has become His permanent residence.

This is the precise contrast with the Old Covenant experience. The Spirit came upon Gideon — the Hebrew word labash (H3847) pictures the Spirit clothing Himself with Gideon like a garment, enveloping him from the outside for a specific moment and mission. That is glorious. But it is different from taking up residence within. Gideon was worn by the Spirit for a battle. Believers are indwelt by the Spirit for life.

The Power: What Kind of Spirit Has Moved In

Paul goes out of his way to identify whose Spirit this is: ‘the Spirit of Him who raised Jesus from the dead.’ He could have simply written ‘the Holy Spirit.’ He chose instead to identify this Spirit by His most dramatic recorded act in history.

The resurrection was not a quiet, gradual recovery. It was the decisive, violent, irreversible defeat of death. A body that had been completely dead for three days — in a sealed tomb, under Roman guard — stood up. The power required for that event is what Paul says has taken up residence in you.

This is not rhetorical exaggeration. Paul uses four distinct Greek words for power elsewhere in his letters to describe God’s activity: dynamis (inherent miraculous ability), energeia (active, working, operational power), kratos (dominion and ruling authority), and ischus (strength, might). All of these converge in the event of the resurrection. And the Spirit who carried that power now lives in every believer.

The Promise: Zoopoieo and the Life That Flows from Resurrection

The word translated ‘give life’ in verse 11 — or ‘quicken’ in the older translations — is zoopoieo (G2227), from zoe (life) and poieo (to make or produce). It is resurrection vocabulary. The same word is used in 1 Corinthians 15:22 (‘in Christ all shall be made alive’) and in John 5:21 (‘the Son gives life to whom He will’).

Paul is doing something layered here. The most obvious reference is to our future bodily resurrection — because of the Spirit who indwells us, the same power that raised Jesus will one day raise us. But Paul has already been applying Romans 8 to present Christian living throughout the chapter. In verse 13 he says that it is ‘by the Spirit’ that we put to death the deeds of the body and live. The quickening, life-giving work of the Spirit is not only eschatological. It is operative now — in our war against sin, our pursuit of holiness, our endurance under suffering, our capacity to pray, to love, to bear fruit that outlasts us.

The Spirit of resurrection is producing resurrection-quality life in mortal bodies right now. That is what Paul means.

Key Terms at a Glance

TermReferenceDefinition / Significance
oikeo (G3611)Romans 8:9, 11To dwell, to inhabit — permanent residence, not a visit or temporary empowerment
zoopoieo (G2227)Romans 8:11To give life, to quicken — resurrection vocabulary; applies both to future bodily resurrection and present Spirit-empowered living
labash (H3847)Judges 6:34Clothed Himself with Gideon — the Spirit enveloping from outside for a specific task; contrasts with New Covenant indwelling
eis ton aionaJohn 14:16Forever, into the age — Jesus describes the duration of the Spirit’s new covenant presence; permanent, not temporary
ruach (H7307)Ezekiel 37:9Breath, wind, Spirit — the same word in Ezekiel’s vision and throughout the OT for the Spirit’s animating presence

VI. A WORD ABOUT OLD TESTAMENT SALVATION

This is the moment to address something carefully. If we are saying that the indwelling of the Spirit is a New Covenant blessing, what does that mean for Old Testament believers? Were they saved? Did they have the Spirit at all?

The answer is unambiguous: yes. Old Testament saints were genuinely saved by grace through faith, looking forward to the redemption that would be accomplished in Christ. Abraham ‘believed God, and it was accounted to him for righteousness’ (Genesis 15:6, Romans 4:3). David, despite his failures, clung to God’s mercy and was described as a man after God’s own heart. The entire ‘hall of faith’ in Hebrews 11 is populated with men and women who pleased God, received divine approval, and were described as strangers and pilgrims seeking a heavenly city.

No one — in any era — comes to saving faith apart from the Spirit’s regenerating work. That work was real and present for every Old Testament believer. We are not saying the Spirit was absent from them. We are saying the Spirit’s mode of operation was different from what became available after the resurrection.

The New Covenant brought a new arrangement — not a new God, not a new gospel, not a new means of salvation, but a new and closer mode of divine presence. The Spirit who worked in and through Old Testament saints from the outside and above now takes up permanent, internal, sealed residence within every believer in Christ. The difference is not between saved and unsaved. It is between partial fulfillment and full possession of the promised gift.

VII. BEFORE AND AFTER: A CONTRAST THAT SHOULD CHANGE HOW WE LIVE

Old Covenant — The Spirit Comes UponSelected individuals for specific tasksExternal empowerment — clothing, coming uponCould be withdrawn — as from Saul (1 Samuel 16:14)David prays: “Do not take Your Holy Spirit from me”New Covenant — The Spirit Moves InEvery believer, permanently — “you are not in the flesh but in the Spirit” (Romans 8:9)Internal residence — oikeo, “dwells within”Sealed until the day of redemption (Ephesians 1:13-14)Jesus promises: “He may abide with you forever” (John 14:16)

The word ‘forever’ in John 14:16 is eis ton aiona — literally, ‘into the age,’ meaning perpetually, without end, for all time. This is not a lease that expires. The Spirit who came upon Elijah for moments of supernatural power now lives permanently within every person who has confessed Christ and received new life.

Paul pressed this point even further in Ephesians 1:13-14. He described believers as those who ‘were sealed with the Holy Spirit of promise, who is the guarantee of our inheritance until the redemption of the purchased possession.’ The word ‘sealed’ — sphragizo (G4972) — refers to the ancient practice of marking a document or container with a king’s seal, indicating ownership and guaranteeing authenticity. The Spirit is God’s seal on us. We belong to Him. The seal holds. Even when we stumble and grieve the Spirit, Ephesians 4:30 makes clear that we remain sealed. The security is not in our performance. It is in His promise.

David was terrified of losing what we cannot lose. That is not a reason for presumption. It is a reason for gratitude so deep it should restructure how we approach every day.

VIII. LIVING AS PEOPLE IN WHOM RESURRECTION POWER DWELLS

The great danger of this truth is that it becomes interesting theology without becoming transformative reality. A.W. Tozer observed something devastating about the modern church: if the Holy Spirit were withdrawn from most of what we do, ninety-five percent of it would continue and no one would notice the difference. By contrast, if the Spirit had been withdrawn from the New Testament church, ninety-five percent of what they did would have immediately stopped.

The question is not whether the Spirit is available. He is. He has moved in. The question is whether we are responsive — whether we live with any awareness that resurrection power has taken up residence within us.

What does it look like to live in the light of Romans 8:11?

It means that our struggle against sin is not a matter of willpower alone. The Spirit who raised Jesus from the dead is working within us to put to death the deeds of the body (Romans 8:13). We are not fighting alone. We are fighting with a very specific kind of help — the same power that broke death is on the side of our sanctification.

It means that our suffering is not without resource. The Spirit who indwells us is simultaneously interceding for us with groanings too deep for words (Romans 8:26). When we do not know what to pray, when the weight is too heavy for language, the Spirit within us takes up the work we cannot articulate. The God who raised Jesus knows how to sustain the people in whom His Spirit lives.

It means that our weakness is not disqualifying. Paul had already argued in Romans 8:3 that ‘what the Law could not do, in that it was weak through the flesh, God did by sending His own Son.’ The Law was glorious, but it could command without empowering. It was a mirror that showed you your dirty face but could not wash it. The Spirit does what the Law could not: He causes us to walk in God’s statutes from the inside out, exactly as Ezekiel promised (Ezekiel 36:27).

And it means that our witness in the world carries a different weight than mere moral persuasion. Jesus told His disciples in Acts 1:8 that they would receive power — dynamis — when the Holy Spirit came upon them, and that they would be His witnesses. The same word for power that describes the resurrection event describes what the Spirit supplies for our testimony. We are not simply commending a good idea. We are witnesses sustained and empowered by the Spirit of the risen Christ.

CONCLUSION: A NEW ADDRESS FOR THE ETERNAL GOD

The tabernacle was constructed with extraordinary care — gold, silver, and bronze, fine linen, skilled artisans filled with the Spirit for the task. It was the place where God’s presence dwelt among His people. And it was glorious. The shekinah that filled it was real. The worship conducted before it was genuine. The men and women who sought God there were people of faith.

But they were seeking God in a place. After the resurrection, God comes to seek His people in a person — in you.

Paul’s language in 1 Corinthians 6:19 is almost too audacious to absorb: ‘Do you not know that your body is the temple of the Holy Spirit who is in you, whom you have from God?’ The temple. Not a place like the temple. The same word — naos, the innermost sanctuary, the Holy of Holies. Every believer in Christ is the place where God has chosen to dwell by His Spirit.

The prophets saw it coming. Ezekiel’s valley of dry bones stood up as a vast army, animated by the breath of God. The promise was clear: I will put My Spirit within you. Joel looked ahead to the day when old and young, slave and free, men and women would all receive the Spirit’s outpouring.

That day came. It came through the cross, where sin was atoned for. It came through the empty tomb, where death was defeated. It came through the ascension, where Christ was glorified. It came at Pentecost, when the Spirit descended and has never since retreated.

And it came to you, at the moment you trusted Christ.

David prayed that the Spirit would not be taken from him. You live on the other side of the promise David was looking toward. The same Spirit who raised Jesus from the dead — the Spirit of dynamis and energeia and kratos and ischus, the Spirit who breathed life into a valley of bleached bones, who clothed Himself with frightened farmers and made them deliverers — that Spirit has made your body His permanent home.

The question is not whether the power is present. It is whether we are paying attention.

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

Use these questions individually or with your Bible study group to go deeper into the truths of this post.

  1. Before reading this post, how would you have described what was different for believers before and after the resurrection of Jesus? Has your understanding shifted? In what way?
  2. Read Psalm 51:11 in context. What does David’s fear of losing the Spirit reveal about the Old Covenant arrangement? What emotions does that prayer evoke in you when you consider it?
  3. The Spirit ‘came upon’ Gideon (Judges 6:34) but ‘dwells in’ New Covenant believers (Romans 8:9). How would you explain that distinction to someone who has never heard it before? What practical difference should it make?
  4. Ezekiel 37 uses the image of a valley of dry bones coming to life through the Spirit’s breath. What areas of your life — spiritually, relationally, vocationally — feel most like that valley right now? How does this passage speak to those areas?
  5. Romans 8:11 connects the Spirit’s indwelling directly to the resurrection. Why does the resurrection specifically matter for what the Spirit is able to do in and through believers? What would be lost if Jesus had not risen?
  6. A.W. Tozer observed that if the Spirit were withdrawn from most of what modern churches do, ninety-five percent of it would continue uninterrupted. How does that land with you? What would it look like to live and minister in greater dependence on the Spirit who has moved in?
  7. The post distinguishes between the Spirit’s coming upon Old Covenant believers for tasks and His permanent sealing of New Covenant believers. Does the permanence of the Spirit’s indwelling give you greater assurance, greater responsibility, or both? Explain.
  8. Read Ezekiel 36:26-27. God promised not only to put His Spirit within His people but to cause them to walk in His statutes. How does that change the way you think about obedience — is it primarily effort, dependence, or some combination? How should it show in daily life?
And I will pray the Father, and He will give you another Helper, that He may abide with you forever — the Spirit of truth, whom the world cannot receive, because it neither sees Him nor knows Him; but you know Him, for He dwells with you and will be in you.John 14:16-17, NKJV

Discover more from Hank's Bible Study Resources

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.



Leave a Reply

The Believer’s Creed

I believe in the eternal God— 
Father, Son, and Holy Spirit— 
One in essence, infinite in glory, 
the Maker of heaven and earth, 
whose wisdom shaped all things seen and unseen. 

I believe in Jesus Christ, 
the only begotten Son of God, 
conceived by the Holy Spirit, 
born of the Virgin Mary, 
holy and humble, yet Lord of all. 
He suffered under Pontius Pilate, 
was crucified, died, and was buried; 
He descended into the depths of hell, 
and on the third day He rose victorious. 
He ascended into heaven, 
and now reigns at the right hand of the Father, 
from where He will come again 
to judge the living and the dead. 

I believe in the Holy Spirit, 
the breath and power of God within us, 
who gives life, convicts hearts, and sustains faith. 
Through the Spirit, the Church is made holy, 
a communion of saints across all generations. 
I believe in the forgiveness of sins, 
the resurrection of the body, 
and life everlasting in the presence of God. 

I believe in the sacred mystery of the Trinity— 
not three gods, but one holy unity: 
Father, Son, and Spirit—eternal, unchanging, divine. 

I believe in the sacred story revealed in Scripture: 
that from the beginning, light has warred against darkness, 
and though the enemy rose in pride, 
God’s promise prevailed through the Seed— 
Christ Jesus, born of a woman, 
who triumphed through His cross and empty tomb. 

I believe salvation is a gift of grace— 
received by faith, sealed by repentance, 
and made real through the transforming love of God. 

I believe the Bible is the inspired Word of God, 
a lamp for our path and truth for every soul. 

I believe in the call of baptism— 
a burial of the old, a rising to new life in Christ. 

I believe the Holy Spirit empowers believers 
with gifts of healing, wisdom, and tongues, 
that we may glorify God and serve the world in love. 

I believe in divine healing, 
for the power that raised Christ from the grave 
still moves with mercy among His people. 

The Believer’s Charge 

We believe that we are called and anointed— 
not as spectators, but as servants of the living God. 
We are His witnesses in all the earth, 
ambassadors of reconciliation and bearers of His light. 

We believe that Christ has commissioned us 
to go into the world and proclaim His gospel, 
to speak truth to the lost and hope to the broken, 
to open blind eyes and set captives free. 
In His name we move without fear, 
for the Spirit goes before us with power and signs. 

We believe the promise of our Lord: 
that these signs will follow those who believe— 
we shall cast out demons in His name, 
speak with new tongues of heavenly fire, 
lay hands upon the sick and see them restored, 
tread upon the works of the enemy, 
and walk in the authority of the risen Christ. 

We believe that the Spirit within us 
confirms the Word with power and grace— 
that we are vessels of His love, 
agents of His mercy, 
and temples of His presence. 

We choose to live as those sent by God, 
our hearts aflame with His gospel, 
our hands ready to serve, 
our voices lifted in praise, 
our lives poured out for His glory. 

The Blessed Hope

I believe in the glorious return of Jesus Christ, 
who will restore all things 
and reign in righteousness and peace. 

And I believe in eternal life— 
the home prepared for the redeemed, 
and the solemn truth of judgment for the unrepentant. 

This is our faith, our confession, our calling, and our hope. 
To God be the glory—forever and ever. 
Amen.

Discover more from Hank's Bible Study Resources

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Discover more from Hank's Bible Study Resources

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading